Before we generalize this method of complementation we should recall . It shows that each action of the form can be considered as an action of on or as an action of on . Hence each such action of on gives rise to an action of on and leads us to the discussion of the Involution Principle. We call a group element an involution if and only if . The Involution Principle is a method of counting objects by simply defining a nice involution on a suitably chosen set and using the fact that has orbits of length 1 (the selfenantiomeric orbits) and of length 2 (which form the enantiomeric pairs) only. A typical example is the complementation of graphs which is, for , an involution on the set of graphs on vertices. An even easier case is described in
. Examples We wish to prove that the number of divisors of is odd if and only if is a square. In order to do this we consider the set of these divisors and define
This mapping is an involution, if , and obviously is odd if and only if has a fixed point, i.e. if and only if there exists a divisor such that , or, in other words, if and only if .
A less trivial example is the following proof (due to D. Zagier) of the fact that every prime number which is congruent 1 modulo 4 can be expressed as a sum of two squares of positive natural numbers. Consider the set
The following map is an involution on (exercise ):
This involution has exactly one fixed point, namely , if , therefore must be odd, and consequently the involution
possesses a fixed point, too, which shows that , a sum of two squares.
Exercises
E . Check the details of the second example in .